Vice President Kamala Harris drew wide attention when she called a section about slavery in Florida’s new middle school social studies standards an "insult."
"They push forward revisionist history," Harris said July 20 at a national convention of Delta Sigma Theta Sorority Inc. "Just yesterday, in the state of Florida, they decided middle school students will be taught that enslaved people benefited from slavery. They insult us in an attempt to gaslight us, and we will not stand for it — we who share a collective experience in knowing we must honor history and our duty in the context of legacy."
Harris revisited the subject in Jacksonville, Florida, July 21. "They want to replace history with lies," she said.
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, speaking in Utah that day, said he "wasn’t involved" in writing the standards, but he defended them as being "rooted in whatever is factual."
"They’re probably going to show that some of the folks that eventually parlayed, you know, being a blacksmith into doing things later in life," he told reporters.
The Republican National Committee accused Harris of telling a "complete lie." Conservative critics said Harris was focusing exclusively on one part of the standards.
Although the new standards include many conventional lesson points about the history of slavery, they also include a sentence that enslaved people developed skills that "could be applied for their personal benefit" — and this has drawn heated rebuttals from historians, who consider it factually misleading and offensive for seeming to find a silver lining in slavery.
Florida’s new standards say ‘slaves developed skills’
The Florida Board of Education approved new social studies standards July 19 following a law passed by the legislature in 2022, known as "Stop Wrongs Against Our Kids and Employees Act" or the "Stop W.O.K.E. Act."
The law bans workplaces and schools from teaching that anyone must feel guilt based on their race as a result of actions by others in the past. Earlier this year, Florida rejected a new high school Advanced Placement course on Black studies.
The 216-page standards document covers a broad sweep of Black history, along with topics such as the Holocaust, world history and geography. It includes different standards for elementary, middle and high school students.
The part of Florida’s new standards that Harris was citing is for grades six through eight. It says:
"Examine the various duties and trades performed by slaves (e.g., agricultural work, painting, carpentry, tailoring, domestic service, blacksmithing, transportation)."
The controversial part is in this "benchmark clarification" about slave labor: "Instruction includes how slaves developed skills which, in some instances, could be applied for their personal benefit."
The rest of the document includes specific standards about slavery, including the development of slavery and the conditions for Africans as they were brought to America. It also covers how slave codes resulted in enslaved people becoming property without rights, abolitionist movements, state and federal laws, revolts by slaves, and the Civil War.
Lessons about Black history include later eras such as Reconstruction, Jim Crow laws, lynchings, contributions of Black Americans during both world wars, and the modern Civil Rights movement.
The standards include some information covering the past two decades, naming an array of historically significant Black Americans who should be included in instruction, such as President Barack Obama, Supreme Court Justices Ketanji Brown Jackson and Clarence Thomas, Secretaries of State Colin Powell and Condoleezza Rice, and Harris, the first Black vice president and first woman in the role.
The standards do not address the Black Lives Matter movement, including nationwide protests following the 2020 murder of George Floyd, a Black man, by Minneapolis police.
Working group members respond to critics
Following state law, the standards were written by a working group that included teachers or school district staff who work in elementary education, social studies or history, or people experienced in teaching Black history.
Two members of the working group, William Allen and Frances Presley Rice, wrote in a statement shared by the education department that the criticism took "a few isolated expressions without context."
Rice is the chair of the National Black Republican Association. Allen lives in Maryland but grew up in Fernandina Beach, Florida. He is a retired political science professor and former dean of James Madison College at Michigan State University.
The intent of the "personal benefit" benchmark, they wrote, was "to show that some slaves developed highly specialized trades from which they benefited" and listed the names of blacksmiths, shoemakers, shipping and industry workers, tailors and teachers.
"Any attempt to reduce slaves to just victims of oppression fails to recognize their strength, courage and resilience during a difficult time in American history," they said. But the Tampa Bay Times found that some of the people listed by the working group were not enslaved when they developed these skills or were freed at a young age. For example, Booker T. Washington, who was enslaved until he was 9, worked in mines and as a houseboy before entering school and later becoming a teacher.
In an interview with PolitiFact, Allen argued the examples apply even if they developed skills after slavery. He noted that the title of Washington’s autobiography was "Up From Slavery."
"They benefited from the skills, not the slavery," Allen told PolitiFact.
Experts criticized Florida’s social studies standards
Multiple experts on Black history and racism in the United States said the language used in Florida’s standards about enslaved people learning skills is misleading.
Marvin Dunn, a psychology professor emeritus at Florida International University, has authored several books on the history of African Americans.
"Most enslaved people had no special skills at all that benefited them following their enslavement," Dunn said. "For almost all their skill was picking cotton. An enslaved man who was made to be a blacksmith might have been a king had he not been captured and taken from his country. Is he supposed to be grateful? Enslavement prevented people from becoming who and what they might have been and that was slavery's greatest injury to humankind."
Dunn added that "there was no upside to slavery that applied to the enslaved."
Katheryn Russell-Brown, a law professor and director of the Race and Crime Center for Justice at the University of Florida, said the standards lack important context.
Russell-Brown said the standards offer "no discussion" of people who enslaved others. Much of the attention given to white people relates to how whites stood up against slavery, such as assisting with the Underground Railroad and support for Reconstruction policies for freed Blacks after the Civil War. It includes some information about groups opposed to "American equality," such as the Ku Klux Klan.
Bruce Levine, an emeritus professor of history at the University of Illinois and author of "Half Slave & Half Free: The Roots of Civil War," was one of several scholars of the period who told PolitiFact that they rejected the value of spotlighting "skills" learned while enslaved.
"Very simply, can you imagine saying this about ‘skills’ developed in Nazi forced-labor camps?" he said.
Carol Anderson, an African American studies professor at Emory University, said the standards represent an "old argument that slavery was a benevolent institution that benefited the enslaved."
"It has the racist underpinning of treating Africans as if they had no skills prior to being kidnapped from their homelands and trafficked to America," Anderson said. "In fact, it was Africans’ skills in cultivating tobacco, sugar and rice that proved beneficial to the enslavers and built the inordinate wealth of the United States. The question itself is dehumanizing."
Added Ashley Rogers Berner, director of the Johns Hopkins Institute for Education Policy: "It is not common for state standards to include language about the ‘benefit’ to enslaved persons of learning trades."
Our ruling
Harris said Florida "decided middle school students will be taught that enslaved people benefited from slavery."
That is not the only lesson Florida students would be taught under the standards that also include many other aspects of Black history and slavery. But the one Harris cited is included, and has drawn significant criticism.
The middle school standards approved by the Florida state education board say students should learn about "skills" learned by slaves that could be "applied for their personal benefit." Several historians who have studied slavery cast doubt on this lesson’s educational value.
We rate this statement Mostly True.
Our Sources
- White House, Remarks by Vice President Harris at the Delta Sigma Theta Sorority Inc. National Convention, July 20, 2023
- Florida Department of Education spokesperson Alex Lanfranconi, Tweet, July 20, 2023
- Florida State Board of Education, Agenda and Florida’s State Academic Standards – Social Studies, 2023, July 19, 2023
- Politico, New Florida teaching standards say African Americans received some ‘personal benefit’ from slavery, July 20, 2023
- Tampa Bay Times, Florida education board OKs Black history standards amid criticism, July 19, 2023
- Tampa Bay Times, Benefited from slavery? Critics say some of the state’s examples were never even slaves. July 21, 2023
- People, Florida middle schoolers will now be taught that slavery had ‘personal benefit’ for enslaved people, July 20, 2023
- NBC News, New Florida standards teach that Black people benefited from slavery because it taught useful skills, July 20, 2023
- BBC News, Florida's new black history curriculum 'sanitised', say critics, July 20, 2023
- Channel 10 Tampa Bay, Florida Department of Education stacks Black history task force with DeSantis allies, June 8, 2023
- Dr William Allen, Tweet, July 21, 2023
- Republican National Committee, Tweet, July 20, 2023
- The Independent, "DeSantis defends Florida curriculum that suggests slaves benefited from forced labour," July 23, 2023
- Email interview with Bruce Levine, emeritus professor of history at the University of Illinois and author of "Half Slave & Half Free: The Roots of Civil War," July 21, 2023
- Email interview, Ashley Rogers Berner, associate professor, Director of the Institute for Education Policy at Johns Hopkins University, July 21, 2023
- Email interview, Marvin Dunn, psychology professor emeritus at Florida International University, July 21, 2023
- Email interview, Carol Anderson, Charles Howard Candler Professor of African American Studies Emory University, July 21, 2023
- Telephone interview, Katheryn Russell-Brown, a law professor and director of the Race and Crime Center for Justice at the University of Florida, July 21, 2023
- Telephone interview, Dr. William B Allen, Emeritus Dean and Professor at Michigan State University, July 24, 2023
Copyright 2023 WLRN 91.3 FM. To see more, visit WLRN 91.3 FM. 9(MDAyNDY5ODMwMDEyMjg3NjMzMTE1ZjE2MA001))
