Some hospitals in the Tampa Bay region and around the U.S. struggled with a spike in health care-associated infections during the COVID-19 pandemic, according to a safety analysis released this month.
Experts with The Leapfrog Group, a nonprofit that issues hospital safety ratings twice a year, cautioned about the rise in infections in their latest rankings. Many Florida hospitals still received A ratings, while others saw a dip in their grades.
Health care-associated infections are illnesses patients develop while in the hospital or as a result of their stay.
“They can have serious complications, they can lengthen hospitalization stays, add to cost and can actually even lead to death in some cases,” said Katie Stewart, Leapfrog’s director of health care ratings.
The analysis compared infections rates from this data cycle, which covered late 2021 and 2022, to pre-pandemic levels. It found the average risk of MRSA, central line-associated bloodstream infections and catheter-associated urinary tract infections rose to five-year highs.
Incidences of bloodline infections rose by 60% nationally, MRSA increased by 37% and UTI’s by 19%.
At the time, many hospitals were struggling with patient surges as the delta and omicron variants sent COVID-19 admissions soaring.
“I think we saw there were lapses in protocols that had been set in place to reduce the number of health care-associated infections,” Stewart said. “We certainly know there were stresses on the workforce, not just in terms of staffing shortages, but also burden and morale and supply chain issues.”
More recent data suggests hospitals are moving in the right direction, but Stewart says there is more work to be done.
The Leapfrog Group weighs over 30 measures to generate its safety grades, including patient experience, staffing levels and practices in place to prevent adverse events, among others.
How Tampa Bay fared
But some hospitals say the rankings don't paint the full picture. Tampa General Hospital, which dropped from a B to a C, said it performs more complex surgeries than some other facilities. Those surgeries are more likely to result in infections.
“Leapfrog’s criteria weigh rates of infection heavily that are common among these complex cases, but that Tampa General providers are highly skilled and experienced at managing,” hospital officials said in a statement. “While we're disappointed to see a drop in our rating by 0.09%, the rating does not reflect our unwavering commitment to be the safest and most innovative academic health system in America.”
Officials noted the hospital is also “the only academic medical center in the country that has received two key safety qualifications from the international accreditation organization DNV,” while adding that staff is implementing an “aggressive plan” to improve its Leapfrog rating.
Many HCA Florida hospitals in the region received A- or B- ratings, although the Oak Hill facility in Brooksville dropped from a B to a C.
“HCA Florida Oak Hill Hospital continues to grow and expand services to meet the community need and has earned numerous recent quality accolades including being named among the Top 5% of Hospitals in the Nation for Surgical Care in 2023 by Healthgrades,” said Debra McKell, media relations director for the West Florida division, in an email.
HCA Florida Highlands hospital in Sebring, which is not in the same division, downgraded from C to D.
Several AdventHealth hospitals in the region fared well with A ratings, but facilities in Dade City, Sebring and Zephyrhills dropped to a B, while its locations in Lake Wales and Davenport downgraded to C and D, respectively. The hospital cited pandemic challenges including staff and resource shortages as contributing factors and said it has already started working on improving patient safety.
“We have taken several steps to provide the highest level of care possible during the pandemic and beyond,” said Robin McGuinness, senior executive officer and chief nurse executive of AdventHealth West Florida Division. “This includes implementing enhanced infection control measures, providing ongoing training to our staff and leveraging the latest technology for patient care.”
Manatee Memorial Hospital dropped from a C to D. The hospital has not responded to requests for comment.
Here’s how hospitals around the Tampa Bay region ranked:
A rating
AdventHealth Carrollwood
AdventHealth North Pinellas
AdventHealth Tampa
AdventHealth Wesley Chapel
Bartow Regional Medical Center
HCA Florida Brandon Hospital
HCA Florida Englewood Hospital
HCA Florida Largo Hospital
HCA Florida Pasadena Hospital
HCA Florida Sarasota Doctors Hospital
HCA Florida St. Petersburg Hospital
HCA Florida Trinity Hospital
Mease Countryside Hospital
Mease Dunedin Hospital
Morton Plant Hospital
Morton Plant North Bay Hospital
Sarasota Memorial Hospital
South Florida Baptist Hospital
St. Anthony's Hospital
St. Joseph's Hospital
St. Joseph's Hospital - South
St. Joseph's Hospital North
B rating
AdventHealth Dade City
AdventHealth Sebring
AdventHealth Zephyrhills
HCA Florida Blake Hospital
HCA Florida Northside Hospital
HCA Florida South Shore Hospital
HCA Florida South Tampa Hospital
Lakewood Ranch Medical Center
Winter Haven Hospital
C rating
AdventHealth Lake Wales
Bayfront Health St. Petersburg
Bravera Health Brooksville
Bravera Health Seven Rivers
Bravera Health Spring Hill
HCA Florida Citrus Hospital
HCA Florida Oak Hill Hospital
Lakeland Regional Medical Center
ShorePoint Health Punta Gorda
Tampa General Hospital
D rating
Adventhealth Heart of Florida
HCA Florida Highlands Hospital
Manatee Memorial Hospital
Not graded
Desoto Memorial Hospital
HCA Florida Bayonet Point Hospital
